Find people, places and things. We'll ask thousands of Jamaicans to help you.
I’d consider Hide A While (aka Idle A While Cliffs). Your group might end up having the entire property to yourselves because it’s about 10 villas on the property. This one is one the cliffs rather than the beach however.
https://www.idleawhile.com/resorts/the-cliffs
Well… we certainly weren’t very quiet when we stayed there (lol) and tbh Negril is so small. You have your peace and quiet there and walk down the beach to where the action is. I really don’t stay anywhere else. Either the small hotel on the beach, or the villas with large groups.